Egypt seeks to broker Gaza ceasefire as Hamas, Israel assert demands

Palestinians search the site of an Israeli strike on Dec 20, 2023. PHOTO: REUTERS
International aid groups say Gaza’s 2.3 million people have been driven to the brink of catastrophe. PHOTO: REUTERS
Palestinians gather at the site of an Israeli strike on a mosque in Rafah in the southern Gaza Strip, on Dec 20, 2023. PHOTO: REUTERS
A child injured during Israeli bombardment receives treatment at the Kuwait Hospital in Rafah in the southern Gaza Strip on Dec 20, 2023. PHOTO: AFP
People injured during Israeli bombardment in an ambulance in Rafah in the southern Gaza Strip, on Dec 20, 2023. PHOTO: AFP
An Egyptian Red Crescent truck carrying humanitarian aid at the Israeli side of the Kerem Shalom border crossing with the southern Gaza Strip on Dec 19, 2023. PHOTO: AFP

CAIRO/GAZA/JERUSALEM – The United States said “very serious” negotiations were taking place on a new Gaza ceasefire and release of more Israeli hostages.

But prospects for a deal remained uncertain as Hamas insisted it would not discuss anything less than a complete end to Israel’s offensive in the Palestinian enclave.

Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh visited Egypt on Dec 20 for the first time in more than a month for discussions with Egyptian officials who are seeking to mediate another truce.

A source briefed on the negotiations said envoys were intensively discussing which of the hostages still held by Palestinian militants in Gaza could be freed in a new truce and which Palestinians held in Israeli prisons might be released in return.

Islamic Jihad, a smaller Palestinian militant group that is also holding hostages in Gaza, said its leader would visit Egypt in the coming days as well to discuss a possible end to the war.

“These are very serious discussions and negotiations, and we hope that they lead somewhere,” White House spokesman John Kirby told reporters aboard Air Force One on Dec 20.

But Mr Taher Al-Nono, Mr Haniyeh’s media adviser, told Reuters that Hamas was not willing to discuss releasing more Israeli hostages until Israel ends its military campaign in Gaza and the volume of humanitarian aid to Palestinian civilians increases.

“The issue of prisoners can be negotiated after these two matters are achieved. We cannot talk about negotiations while Israel continues its aggression. Discussing any proposal related to prisoners must occur after the cessation of aggression,” Mr Nono said in an interview in Cairo.

Hamas rejects any further temporary pause in Israel’s military campaign and says it will discuss only a permanent ceasefire. “We have talked with our brothers in Egypt, outlining our stance on this aggression and the urgent need to stop it as a top priority,” Mr Nono said.

Israel has insisted all remaining women and infirm men among the hostages be released, the source briefed on the negotiations said, declining to be identified. Palestinians convicted of serious offences could be on the list of prisoners to be freed by Israel.

Remote video URL

Biden says US ‘pushing’ hostage deal

Israel launched its campaign in the Gaza Strip with the aim of annihilating Hamas after its fighters raided Israel on Oct 7. They took some 240 hostages and killed 1,200 people, according to Israel.

Since then, Israel has waged a massive ground and air assault on the seaside enclave, killing nearly 20,000 people, Gaza’s health ministry said. Several thousand more bodies are believed to be trapped under rubble.

International aid groups say Gaza’s 2.3 million people have been driven to the brink of catastrophe by wholesale destruction that has driven 90 per cent of them from their homes and left many malnourished and gravely short of clean water and medical care.

US President Joe Biden on Dec 20 said he did not expect a second Israel-Hamas hostage release deal to be struck soon, though he added in remarks to reporters: “We’re pushing.”

Mr Haniyeh’s visit to Egypt was a rare personal intervention in diplomacy, something he has done in the past only when progress seemed likely.

He last travelled to Egypt in early November before the announcement of the only ceasefire in the Gaza war so far, a week-long pause that saw the release of about 110 of Hamas’ hostages.

Israel has not commented publicly on the talks in Egypt. But it has ruled out a permanent ceasefire and says it will agree only to limited humanitarian pauses until Hamas is defeated.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu repeated on Dec 20 that the war would end only with Hamas eradicated, all hostages freed and Gaza posing no more threat to Israel.

“Whoever thinks we will stop is detached from reality... All Hamas terrorists, from the first to the last, are dead men walking,” he said in a statement on Dec 20.

The US, Israel’s closest ally, has stepped up calls in the past week for it to scale down its all-out war into a focused campaign against Hamas leaders and end what Mr Biden has called “indiscriminate bombing” causing huge civilian casualties.

Remote video URL

‘Summarily killed’

The United Nations human rights office said it had received reports that Israeli troops “summarily killed” at least 11 unarmed Palestinians in a possible war crime in Gaza.

The office in the West Bank city of Ramallah said the killings were alleged to have been carried out in the Rimal neighbourhood of Gaza City this week.

It said on Dec 20 it had received “disturbing information alleging that Israeli Defence Forces (the Israeli army) summarily killed at least 11 unarmed Palestinian men”.

The incident “raises alarm about the possible commission of a war crime”, it said, adding that the men were killed in front of their family members.

The report said troops also ordered women and children into a room “and either shot at them or threw a grenade into the room, reportedly seriously injuring some of them, including an infant and a child”.

An Israeli official rejected the claims as “nothing but blood libel”.

“The latest claims are yet another example of the partisan and prejudiced approach against Israel that the OHCHR (Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights) has adopted for years now,” the official said on condition of anonymity.

The Israeli army did not immediately comment.

Spillover

In a serious spillover from the war, Yemen’s Houthi forces have been firing missiles and drones at commercial shipping in the Red Sea to underline support from Iran’s Arab militia proxies for the Palestinians against Israel. The US this week set up a multinational force to ward off the attacks.

On Dec 20, the Houthis’ leader warned they would strike US warships if their forces were targeted by Washington.

The United Nations Security Council was due to vote on Dec 21 on a bid to boost aid to the Gaza Strip after a delay at the request of the US, diplomats said.

Aid into Gaza has gradually increased in recent days after the opening of a second crossing into the enclave.

On Dec 20, Cyprus and Israel said they were exploring opening a sea route to bring more aid in, though no final agreement was reached. REUTERS

Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.